1 - 20 of 290 Works in Shadow Milk Cookie Redemption (Cookie Run)
Navigation
Listing Works
-
Tags
Summary
Once the Fount of Knowledge, then the Beast of Deceit, and now, a Soul Jam-less, powerless wanderer trapped in his own other realm. This unwelcome plot twist had really thrown a wrench in Shadow Milk’s grand plans for vengeance. And to top it all off? Pure Vanilla was here too! To act saintly and get in his way and poke his nose into everything Shadow Milk was trying to hide. Oh joy! Surely nothing bad could happen!
Will Shadow Milk get his revenge on Dark Enchantress for backstabbing him? Will Pure Vanilla lose his sanity again? With they get back to Earthbread and reclaim their Soul Jams or will they throttle each other first?
Or: Shadow Milk has mommy issues and makes it Pure Vanilla’s problem
Featuring:
- AU where the witches are plot relevant
- Slow burn applies to both the ship and the redemption
- Memory segments of the Fount at the start of each chapter
- Smilk is still villainous before the redemption. Memory snippets of trauma come first while the villainy comes laterWorldbuilding infodump and rambling on twitter @liarssolace
Series
- Part 1 of Witches' Board Game AU
-
Tags
Summary
Shadow Milk is an evil entity who thrives on chaos. His hobby is wrapping cookies in a web of lies to watch their minds and realities collapse. Shadow Milk doesn't care about anything or anyone, except for one exception: Candy Apple and Black Sapphire.
He's aware that a war will soon break out that could devastate all of Earthbread, and his priority now is to protect the only cookies he cares about in this world. So he decides to embark on a journey with them to find a safe place to leave them. Of course, he won't tell them that his plan is to abandon them, nor will they know the true reason for this trip; for them, it's just... a vacation.
Although perhaps this vacation will be more important than they expected and each of them will end up finding the love they didn't know they needed.
-
Tags
Summary
After the Spire, Pure Vanilla Cookie and the Gingergang head back to the Vanilla Kingdom. Pure Vanilla, not wanting to tire the children out after such an exhausting journey, insists they stay in the Vanilla Kingdom until they are ready to return to their kingdom.
Pure Vanilla takes some time to reflect the night after sorting out rooms for Gingerbrave and his friends. He roams his castle, going from room to room, doing nothing but thinking, about his friends, about the spire, about Shadow Milk Cookie. Why had he not accepted his request to be friends?
Suddenly, his souljam started to glow and vibrate. The vibrations and pulses were strong, as if the souljam wanted to break itself from the inside out. Before Pure Vanilla could move a muscle, there was a blinding light, and Pure Vanilla could only shield his eyes from the sight.
As the light started to die down, Pure Vanilla looked up, and it was as if he had seen a ghost. But it would have to be, because the Cookie hovering before him couldn't be the same one who had rejected him. Why was he here? What did he come for? What was his plan?
Series
- Part 1 of JAMMED FATE SERIES
-
Tags
Summary
He’s back here.
He’s back here.
Oh Witches damned, let it be just a nightmare - a demented illusion of his wretched mind.
. . .
He should have known. Should have known that peace would never last, despite much of his Other Half's reassurances.
Sent back to the far past in the midst of war, Shadow Milk finds himself ill-adjusted to who he used to be. Yet, there's one thing he's absolutely certain - he can't allow the Virtues to go down that path, not again.
(Hundreds of years in the future, a shepherd searched and longed.)
-
Tags
Summary
Pure Vanilla Cookie was a hero, having traveled to the Domain of Deceit to slay the wretched beast that lived within the labyrinth of the spire. However, he remembered very little from the event. He didn't feel like a hero, didn't desire to be the only one to walk away. Now he lay in his own defeat, unable to tell his citizens and dear friend that the beast lived, and would be making his return. It was never a lie if he never spoke of the event, right?
Though he was desperate for answers, truthful answers, that only the Master of Deceit could give him.
** First Chapter contains detailed warnings, read carefully!
This work is my current priority and will be updated weekly if not more often <3 -
Tags
Summary
Pure Vanilla Cookie managed to warm Shadow Milk Cookie’s cold heart, redeeming him for good. Soon, Shadow Milk and Pure Vanilla were wed, and lived happily ever after.
That is until a new cookie entered their lives…
Series
-
Tags
Summary
When the holders of the soul-jam of knowledge fought, their magic bursted creating and destroying many things. However, one of the creations was unique…
They have accidentally created a living child out of pure magic.
____________________________________________________
Sneak peak:
As the trio was searching through the rumbles of their broken home, a piercing cry can be heard from a distance “Is… is that a baby..?” Black-sapphire questioned with confusion.“Keep looking, I will follow the sound. It might be a child from the village.” Their master ordered with an angry tone to his voice.
____________________________________________________
What to expect:
-I am new to writing fanfics.
-English is not my first language.
-The rating might change depends on how I want the story to go.
-This is an AU not cannon to the game.
-I might sometimes mix the lore and the characters of the devsister’s games (Depends).
-No plan for future chapters I am writing whatever comes in mind at the moment.
-I upload randomly. -
Tags
Summary
✛ JUDGMENT IS HERE.
The Ancients may have survived their destined Beasts—but victory came at a price. For every triumph, a shadow remained. Their “other halves,” bitter remnants of those titanic foes, refuse to fade. They linger in hunger and rage, waiting for the day the Heroes fall and the Soul Jams return to their true masters.
…Or so they believed.
For hidden deep within the forest, in the forsaken Witches' Cabin that gave rise to Gingerbrave and his youthful companions, a greater scheme simmered. From shattered lineages emerged four children and their enigmatic leader—the Beast Hunters, harbingers of the Beasts’ reckoning. The sins of the past came alive, setting an ancient cycle in motion.
Driven from their own domains, their pride shattered, the Beasts are left with one desperate refuge—the very Heroes they once sought to destroy. But even the Ancients may not be enough to shield them from the Hunters’ judgment.
Because this is more than survival. For the Beasts, redemption means confronting not just their new predators…
…but themselves.- NEW PROLOGUE
-
Tags
-
Tags
Summary
A look of confusion covered Shadow Milk’s face, stained with a tinge of hope. He listened to the sound of Black Sapphire and Candy Apple yelling in the background, trying to distract himself from the warmth of the sun shining in front of him.
He should have immediately said no. “Curse you,” he’d have said. “Liar.” But he didn’t, because Pure Vanilla’s warmth was akin to freezer burn, coming to a cookie that hadn’t felt anything warm, anything compassionate, in so, so long. Just once, maybe, he could accept a helpful hand. Just once, he could let Pure Vanilla in. What could he lose, if he didn’t have anything to begin with? So in a moment of weakness, he choked out:
“…. Friend?”
(updates weekly :3)
-
Dreams of Vanilla With a Side of Blueberry (You Were In Them) by saturn_j1407b
Fandoms: Cookie Run (Video Game)
17 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
“... I felt it. A minute droplet of longing, hiding in the dark.” Pure Vanilla continued.
“I know it, for I've felt the same.”
Pure Vanilla looked up at Shadow Milk, with his eyes open and him placing a hand on his own Soul Jam, “Yes, Shadow Milk Cookie. No one else but me can truly understand you.”
Shadow Milk hovered against the ground, threatening to drift away from him merely standing still.
“... What?” His voice cracked.
“We shared the same Soul Jam. We can understand each other like no one else can.”
Pure Vanilla shuffled forward, offering a hand slowly to Shadow Milk.“You don't have to be lonely… I'm right here.” Pure Vanilla offered a fond smile.
“Please.”
-
Tags
Summary
"There's also some texts that are in languages we can't decipher, and I heard you mention..” Pure Vanilla trails off, losing his thought process a little.
Shadow Milk's ears perk up from the mention of different languages, as that’s something he’s always been quite fond of. “Language deciphering you say~?” he floats down so that he’s at Pure Vanillas eye level, a big smile on his face like he never was unhappy 5 minutes ago. Pure Vanilla doesn’t flinch at the sudden proximity, instead he smiles kindly and simply nods.
“Yes, we thought that perhaps you could help us in that department.” His voice gentle, and Shadow Milk ignores the strange feeling his stomach always gets whenever Pure Vanilla is so gentle with him. Because it's stupid.-----other summery :) ----
Basically Shadow Milk messes up and sends Pure Vanilla and White Lily back in time. This sets off a huge set of events in the stressful times of war.-Title is the song «Another Believer» by Rufus Wainwright from Meet the Robinsons :)
-
Tags
Summary
Pure Vanilla overworks himself and uses too much of his magic. This ends up backfiring on him, causing him to become extremely sick. Luckily, his friends and partner are here to care for him! But will they be able to figure out what's wrong?
-
Tags
Summary
Pure Vanilla and Shadow Milk share their feelings for each other and get together. As they go through the ups and downs of their blossoming relationship, other events start to unfold. Pure Vanilla becomes pregnant, and they need to start preparing to become new parents, they have to share their traumas and insecurities, and prepare for the incoming storm.
-Pure Vanilla is a girl in this! Not erasing gay couples-! Shadow Milk is genderfluid and is also a girl sometimes, trust. YURI!
-
Tags
Summary
Shadow Milk Cookie has a lot to think about after what he did to Pure Vanilla Cookie and vice versa. Pure wants to start over, become friends before the whole corruption. But Shadow Milk is fearful of the possible future. He doesn’t want to hurt Pure again. He just wants Vanilla to love him.
-
Tags
Summary
A throbbing pain in his beautiful face. Crumbs falling to his clammy hands. A voice.
“... You do not have to be alone anymore. I am right here.”
The light, so blindingly dazzling, in the form of a cookie and a king- or, in better terms, a cookie and a king, taking a form of light- extending his hand towards another, reaching, pulling.
The other has no words.
“Let me be your friend.”
“... Friend…?”
-
Tags
Summary
How foolish to let someone get close to you, especially when they had betrayed you once before.
Shadow Milk freezes as another thought suddenly squeezes to the front of his mind.
The betrayal of someone close.
What could be more despair-inducing than that?
A wicked grin spreads on his face. Get close to Pure Vanilla … and betray his trust. It may not physically destroy him, oh, but it would absolutely ruin him. If Pure Vanilla Cookie wanted his friendship so badly, who was Shadow Milk to deny him?Or: Shadow Milk Cookie, after many failed plans, decides to fake a friendship with Pure Vanilla Cookie, get him to trust him, and betray him in a most devastating fashion. How it ends up working, however...
-
Tags
Summary
Truths are supposed to be honest and good,
While Deceits can be really mean and bad.
But what if, Deceits are actually really good to tell?
As telling the truth can lead someone to get their feelings hurt really bad,
And even worse, fall into despair.
Especially if the cookie who thinks that, is the Beast of Deceit himself…
Really makes you think…
Huh, Pure Vanilla Cookie?
Or my rewrite of Episode 7 & 8 of Beast-Yeast.
Series
- Part 29 of My Cookie Run Fanfics
- Part 6 of My Rewrites
-
Let Chaos be Divine (God, What a Lovely Sin) by huijini, JadeTheEevee
Fandoms: Cookie Run (Video Game)
11 Oct 2025
Tags
Summary
A fix-it au, with ocs! Focuses on the beast's redemption, the Virtues, and a sixth soul jam.
-
Tags
Summary
What happens when two cookies each bound to the other finally face their feelings for the other despite everyone else against it? What happens when a liar is faced with the truth of their own emotions and a revered hero realises how much he truly desires having his supposed evil other half besides him(what is the actual truth of this story?)